Facing Down the Demon of Perfectionism

Giving up isn’t always a bad thing. There are many legitimate reasons to give up on any task. Maybe you’ve accomplished enough of it already. Maybe the cost of continuing outweighs the benefits of succeeding. Or maybe you’ve just lost interest in the goal. But there are some bad reasons to give up as well.

One of those bad reasons is a demon that’s haunted Shawn Spradling most of his life, and it’s probably haunting you, too. I interviewed Shawn in his office at Center Pointe Christian Church in West Chester, Ohio, to get his personal story. As always, it’s more interesting to listen to my guests tell their own story, which you can do by clicking the play button above. But below is a shortened version of his story that was published in my book, Parenting with a Story.

Shawn grew up in Mount Sterling, Kentucky, a city of about six thousand people in the north-central part of the state, right in the heart of basketball country. At that time, school basketball teams for boys started as early as the fourth grade, and Shawn was quick to be among them. In those early grades, anyone who wanted to sign up could be on the team.

But by Shawn’s seventh-grade year, the teams were more selective, which meant to earn a spot he had to make it through tryouts. That made Shawn anxious.

I was really concerned I’d get cut, primarily because it would be embarrassing, and I’d have to explain that,” he recalls.

Tryouts were scheduled after school every day for a week. All the boys who wanted to go out for the team played together and went through drills for the first couple of days. By the third day, the coach started making cuts. At the end of the hour, names of the players remaining on the team were placed on the board. If your name wasn’t on the list, you didn’t make it.

Shawn made it through the first cut, and the second one. But going into the final day of tryouts, he was nervous. He knew how many spots were available on the team. And by now he knew all the other boys and what their skill levels were. So he started doing the math in his head. And he didn’t like his odds. “What if I don’t make it?” he asked himself. The thought of being cut weighed heavier and heavier on Shawn, and that fear eventually overwhelmed him. He started looking for an exit strategy.

So on the last day of tryouts, Shawn simply didn’t show up. Instead of going to the gym after school, he got on the bus like he would have on any other normal school day and went home.

When Shawn’s father got home from work, he found his son playing basketball in the driveway. When he asked him why he wasn’t at basketball tryouts, Shawn told him,

I just decided I didn’t want to play.”

Shawn thought that would be easier to say—to himself probably as much as to anyone else—than it would be to explain that “I didn’t make the cut, I didn’t get picked, or I wasn’t good enough.” But Dad saw through that immediately. Shawn described his reaction this way: “He was absolutely furious with me, that I would quit on the last day.”

So there Shawn was, playing out his exit strategy, perhaps considering if he was right. Was suffering his father’s disappointment indeed easier than his own embarrassment of getting cut? And if that’s where his ordeal ended, he might have concluded that he was right. But it got worse.

That night, Shawn’s best friend, Brady, called him and asked him why he wasn’t at tryouts. Shawn practiced his rehearsed answer once again. And once again, his audience saw through it. That’s when Brady told Shawn something he didn’t expect to hear.

But Shawn, you’d already made the team!”

Apparently, the coach had confided in Brady that he’d been debating between Shawn and another boy named Jason. But he’d already decided to give the spot to Shawn. He just hadn’t posted that decision yet. Unfortunately, since Shawn didn’t show up on the last day of tryouts, he had to give the spot to Jason.

You can imagine Shawn’s disappointment, both in knowing that he could have been on the team and in ending his basketball career in such a cowardly manner.

Looking back, Shawn knows that wasn’t to be the only time something like that happened.

I picked up a guitar a long time ago. But I couldn’t play it perfectly right away. So I quit. I still have the guitar. And I still can’t play it. I put a lot of pressure on myself to be perfect. If I couldn’t excel at it, I didn’t even try.” He admits, “I’ve missed a lot of opportunities in life because I was too afraid to disappoint myself and other people.”

One example he described was when he was a student at Cincinnati Christian University. “There was a preaching contest every year. You’d write a sermon and deliver it in front of a few of the professors. The top three finalists got to preach in chapel. It was a huge honor. At the time I felt like I was gifted to preach, and several of my friends encouraged me to do it. But here’s the lie I stood behind: I told them, and myself, ‘you know, I’m not a fan of preaching contests. I just don’t think it’s right to preach for a silly contest. It demeans the act.’

But the real reason was that I was afraid I wouldn’t get picked. I didn’t want my name read off as ‘the guy who lost.’ So I never even tried it. I still regret that decision.”

Shawn only turned the corner in this battle about seven years ago, at the age of thirty-five. He was offered the senior pastor role at Center Pointe Christian Church in West Chester, Ohio. Instead of jumping quickly at the opportunity to take his first senior pastor role, leading a congregation of 1,100, he spent weeks debating with himself if he was good enough.

Then one day, while he was still wrestling with this decision, his mother told his wife, Janelle,

I think he’ll do a really good job as long as he understands it won’t always be perfect.”

And that’s when Shawn finally had a name for his demon. It was perfectionism. He faced the truth as he described it, that “perfectionism had stolen a lot of my joy in life.”

Knowing he’d been unsuccessfully fighting this demon for two decades, Shawn realized he couldn’t continue to fight alone. He found his solution, as he describes it, “in placing more dependence on God. I had to stop relying on my own strength and talents and wisdom.”

Shawn decided to take the job and succeed or fail “according to whatever plan God had for me.” He describes taking that job as “a huge victory for me over perfectionism.” He admits he still struggles with it on occasion. But he finds joy in the small victories now that he knows his enemy and is no longer as afraid of failing.

By the way, Shawn has held the position of senior pastor for eight years now. And it looks like his mom was right. Things aren’t always perfect. But he is doing a great job.

As with all of these stories, I encourage you to share this with your kids, and then have a discussion about it. Here are some questions to get you started:

  1. Which is worse, having your mother or father disappointed in you for quitting or knowing you got cut from a team?
  2. What are you afraid of failing at?
  3. What have you not tried in the past just because you were afraid to
    fail?
  4. How do you know when it is time to give up?

Use these links to subscribe to this podcast on iTunes or Stitcher, or Podbean.

Source: Parenting with a Story: Real-life Lessons in Character for Parents and Children to Share, by Paul Smith.

Paul Smith is one of the world’s leading experts on business storytelling. He’s a keynote speaker, storytelling coach, and bestselling author of the books Lead with a StoryParenting with a Story, and Sell with a Story.

Smith--Sell cover front w forewordParentingWthStoryCOVER smallLeadwithaStoryConnect with him via email here.

Follow him on Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, and Instagram.

Sign up for his newsletter here to get one new story a week delivered to your inbox.

Speak Your Mind

*